Small Dwellings in Modern America: A Tradition Back on Center Stage

Small Houses Have Always Been Part of the Landscape

The current fascination with diminutive living spaces often overlooks the fact that these compact residences are anything but new. Early American settlers typically called modest cabins and cottages home—far smaller than the suburban developments many of us know today. So what caused homes to grow in size over time, and why are smaller footprints coming back into favor?

A Time When You Built It Yourself

In the country's early years, individuals often constructed their own living quarters. If you've ever seen the log cabin where Abraham Lincoln spent his youth, it's more akin to a modern bedroom than a full house. Without modern hardware stores or factories producing materials in bulk, it made sense to keep structures small.

Budgets Shaped Home Sizes

By the late 1800s, professional builders were more common, but homeowners still had to be mindful of expenses. A typical mortgage in the early 20th century required a substantial down payment—half the price of the home in some cases. That meant fewer buyers could afford large properties, which kept square footage under control. Banks simply weren't willing to stretch lending limits beyond a family's genuine ability to pay.

Building Techniques Transformed After World War II

The 1950s ushered in production-line housing methods. Concrete slab foundations and tract construction made it easier and cheaper to produce bigger homes. Families with growing numbers of children found it practical to trade the craftsmanship of older styles for more space and extra bedrooms.

Lending Became Extremely Flexible

In the 1990s and early 2000s, mortgage standards grew increasingly relaxed. Zero-down and no-documentation loans allowed people to purchase houses well beyond their true budgets. This fueled the era of oversized bathrooms, sprawling master suites, and extra rooms that sometimes went unused.

Keeping Up Appearances

The drive to own the largest house on the block also played a role. Headlines about extravagant estates—like the 90,000-square-foot mansion built by a Florida resort developer—demonstrated just how far some would go for status. In many of these cases, it had little to do with practical needs.

The 2008 Mortgage Crisis Changed Everything

Eventually, lax lending led to a market collapse, leaving many people facing foreclosure. Tougher standards returned, requiring solid credit and significant down payments. Overnight, homes that were out of financial reach for most could no longer be financed with ease.

Households Are Getting Smaller

Meanwhile, the generation that drove much of the housing boom—those born in the post-war years—began downsizing. Many retirees sold their larger properties and opted for residences that better fit their empty-nester lifestyles. Around 10,000 individuals from this age group retire every day, making home sales a key part of their retirement strategy.

Rising Prices and Limited Incomes

The average cost of housing in the United States continues to climb, pushing many younger adults out of the conventional home market. At the same time, the nation's earning power hasn't kept pace for a large swath of the population. Many families have far less spending flexibility, and borrowing is once again constrained by stricter rules.

Why the Shift Back to Smaller Homes Was Bound to Happen

With larger houses becoming less practical, the movement toward snug residences was almost inevitable. This is more than a passing fad. The broad social and economic forces driving this shift will likely stay in play for years to come. For investors in mobile home communities, these conditions are especially favorable: interest in smaller living spaces supports long-term stability and growth in this sector.

Final Thoughts

While "micro living" may feel like a bold, new lifestyle trend, history shows that scaled-down homes are as American as early settler cabins. Today's shift is simply a return to principles that once guided home construction—practical dimensions, affordability, and a focus on genuine needs. From an investment standpoint, these factors make mobile home parks an increasingly appealing option for those looking to align with the changing realities of modern housing.

Frank Rolfe
Frank Rolfe has been an investor in mobile home parks for almost 30 years, and has owned and operated hundreds of mobile home parks during that time. He is currently ranked, with his partner Dave Reynolds, as the 5th largest mobile home park owner in the U.S., with around 20,000 lots spread out over 25 states. Along the way, Frank began writing about the industry, and his books, coupled with those of his partner Dave Reynolds, evolved into a course and boot camp on mobile home park investing that has become the leader in this niche of commercial real estate.