Preview:
Rincon Country RV Resorts on the southwest side of Tucson is surrounded by gently rolling hills populated with saguaros. On the highest hill stands a small church with a white cross.
On the last day of June 2023, Norman Butka, a resident of the community, was found dead in a shed next to his home. The temperature was 105 degrees.
The next month, on July 12, Charles Jerabek, staying in an RV near Davis-Monthan Air Force Base, was found dead amid low lying mesquite and scrubby palo verde trees. Heat contributed to his death, according to medical examiner records.
Less than a week later, on July 19 — with the temperature hitting 112...
Read More
Our thoughts on this story:
The medical examiner’s determination of what contributed to the death in each case: environmental heat exposure. Arizona Luminaria requested and analyzed heat-related or heat-contributed death data provided by the Pima County Office of the Medical Examiner to gain an understanding of the lethal impacts of heat on mobile home residents.
This sounds like the beginning of one of those studies that DOGE has been racing to defund.
The simple fact of the matter is that Tucson is incredibly hot in the summer, and nobody can survive there without air conditioning. Google shows the temperature that can kill you from heat stroke is 104 degrees. So this is not a mobile home issue but simply an issue of older people not being exposed to 104 degrees or higher, which means you have to be indoors with the air conditioning on all day long.
If, in fact, more people are dying of heat stroke in mobile home parks than surrounding subdivisions, I would imagine it’s for one of several reasons:
- People in mobile home parks typically do their own yard work, whereas in subdivisions they hire it out. In many of the examples given, the park residents died outside in their yards, not inside.
- People in mobile home parks probably run their air conditioning less to keep their utility bills lower.
- People in mobile home parks like to be outdoors more, which was part of their attraction to living in what equates to a pseudo-RV lifestyle.
You CANNOT jump to the conclusion – as this writer did – that it’s solely because mobile homes are less energy efficient. That’s ridiculous. While mobile homes do have less energy efficiency than a comparable single-family home, that’s not going to take a home with the AC set at 75 degrees and leak enough cool air to drive the temperate to 104 degrees in the home. Give me a break.